In partnership with

Rethinking the Reel: Why It Might Be Time to Reconsider Your Retractable Leash

There's a familiar sight on neighborhood walks: a dog happily trotting ahead, seemingly enjoying newfound freedom at the end of a long, thin leash. For many pet parents, the retractable leash feels like the perfect compromise, giving their furry friend a bit more room to explore while still maintaining a connection. But have you ever considered whether this popular tool is the best choice for your beloved companion?

Perhaps it's time to rethink the reel. While the allure of extra slack is undeniable, digging a little deeper reveals potential drawbacks that could impact your dog's safety, your control, and even the overall enjoyment of your walks.

Sit & Stay Pro Tip — Reeling In Potential Problems

Let's be honest, the initial appeal is strong. That extended length seems to offer your pup a taste of off-leash adventure without the worry of them bolting. They can sniff that intriguing patch of grass a little further away, or investigate that rustling leaf with more enthusiasm. And for us humans, it can feel like we're giving them a little more independence.

However, the very feature that makes retractable leashes appealing – their variable length – is also a significant source of potential problems.

The Control Conundrum

Imagine a sudden encounter with another dog, a cyclist whizzing by, or even just your dog spotting a particularly enticing squirrel. In these crucial moments, the ability to quickly and effectively regain control is paramount. With a long, extended leash, that immediate control is significantly diminished. Fumbling to reel in several feet of slack while your dog is lunging can be difficult, even dangerous. A standard, shorter leash provides a more direct line of communication and allows for quicker, more decisive action.

Mixed Signals and Confused Canines

Dogs thrive on clear communication. A consistent leash length provides a predictable boundary, helping them understand their personal space and your expectations during walks. A retractable leash, constantly changing in length, can send mixed signals. One moment they have ten feet to roam, the next they're abruptly pulled back. This inconsistency can lead to confusion and make it harder for them to learn leash manners.  

The Risk of Injury – For Both of You

The thin cord of a retractable leash can pose a surprising risk of injury. A sudden jerk can cause rope burns to your hands, and if your dog bolts unexpectedly, the force can lead to more serious injuries to both of you. Additionally, the leash itself can become tangled around legs or necks, creating a dangerous situation.

Promoting Pulling, Not Polite Walking

Because retractable leashes often allow dogs to forge ahead, they can inadvertently encourage pulling. Your dog learns that pulling extends their reach, reinforcing the behavior you're likely trying to discourage. Switching to a standard leash can often be a key step in teaching loose-leash walking.  

So, What's the Alternative?

Moving away from a retractable leash doesn't mean sacrificing your dog's enjoyment of their walks. In fact, it can enhance it!

• Consider a standard-length leash (4-6 feet): This provides you with better control and clearer communication with your dog.

• Explore positive reinforcement training: Teach your dog polite leash manners using treats and praise. A well-trained dog will enjoy walking calmly by your side, regardless of the leash length.

• Find safe off-leash areas: If your dog craves more freedom, dedicated dog parks or secure, enclosed spaces can provide a wonderful opportunity to run and play safely.

• Think about a long line (non-retractable): For specific training purposes or controlled exploration in safe areas, a long, non-retractable line can offer more distance while still allowing for consistent communication and control.

Our recommendation to reconsider the retractable leash isn't about judgment; it's about taking a thoughtful look at the tools we use and ensuring they truly serve the best interests of our furry companions. By prioritizing safety, clear communication, and consistent training, we can make our walks more enjoyable and rewarding for both ends of the leash. So, perhaps it's time to reel in those extra feet.

Daily Superfood Support for Aging, Medium-to-Large Dogs

You invest in your own wellness—why not your dog’s?

Designed for medium-to-large dogs, POP-Topper is a science-backed, premium daily supplement developed by animal health researchers in New Zealand.

Each single-serve sachet delivers clean, targeted support with human-grade superfoods like green-lipped mussels (for omega-3s), bilberry (for antioxidants), beef bone broth (for collagen), and kiwi (for vitamin C). No fillers. No additives. Just results.

Especially if your dog’s on kibble and curious about fresh food, POP-Topper fits seamlessly into your routine—and helps support long-term joint, immune, and brain health.

Try POP-Topper—$49/Month (30 servings)

Like newsletters?

Here are some newsletters our readers also enjoy:

Dog Food and Supplement Recalls

Here are the recent recalls and advisories:

• Blue Ridge Beef - Puppy Mix and Kitten Mix for potential salmonella and listeria contamination

• Savage Pet - Cat Food Chicken for potential bird flu exposure

• Wild Coast Raw - Frozen Boneless Free Range Chicken Formula raw pet food for cats for possible bird flu exposure

• Blue Ridge Beef - Natural Mix for potential salmonella

The Smile Section

Reader Pet of the Day - Macie and Logan

If you have a photo and/or story that can make us smile, send it to [email protected].

Vet Recommendation — Retractable Leashes are Dangerous

Veterinarians often advise against the use of retractable leashes due to significant safety risks and hindrances to effective training. The thin cords can cause serious injuries like burns and cuts, and sudden stops can lead to neck or throat trauma for dogs. Furthermore, these leashes offer poor control, potentially encouraging pulling and making training difficult, while also posing a risk of malfunction and loss of control. In busy environments, especially veterinary clinics, retractable leashes can be hazardous, potentially leading to aggression due to dogs entering others' personal space and proving difficult to manage in confined areas, ultimately making them unsuitable for leash-reactive, fearful, or untrained dogs.

Treats

• 🐶 Pup Easter Egg Hunt: Check out this pawsitively adorable doggie Easter egg hunt!

• ✍️ Join Our Facebook Group and Share Photos of Your Pup(s)!

Want your dog to be featured?

We’d love to!

Think your dog can make us smile? Submit a pic to [email protected] with your dog’s name and reference Sit & Stay for a chance to see your pet in our Smile Section!